Ultimate peanut butter pie with chocolate peanut butter toppings

Thanksgiving at Plenty Sweet

Save room. You’ll want pie.

From tart, creamy key lime to chocolate-loaded peanut butter and crumble-topped Dutch apple, bring something worth saving room for.

Order now

Plenty Sweet Bakes is a home bakery focused on simple ingredients, seasonal flavors, and desserts that feel special without being fussy. Everything is baked in small batches with just the right amount of sweetness.

Shop our menu